Skip to main content

Opioid Settlement Money Is Buying Pickleball Courts. The People It Was Paid For Are Still Waiting.

A national investigation tracked $3.7 billion in settlement spending last year. Some went to cardiac monitors, license-plate cameras and a court with a net. In Arizona, the biggest line item is the state prison budget.

ByThe Rize NewsroomNovember 22, 202611 min readOpioids

Elizabeth Burke Beaty has a way of describing opioid settlement money that no county budget office will ever print on a spreadsheet. “This is money from dead people and people left behind,” she told KFF Health News reporters Aneri Pattani and Lydia Zuraw this month. Burke Beaty is in recovery. She runs the Sea Change Recovery Community and Harm Reduction Center in Ocean County, New Jersey, which means she spends her days with the people that money was paid out for: the ones still using, the ones newly out, the ones who buried somebody. When she looks at what some towns bought with it, she asks a question that is harder than it sounds. “Did this come from a place of ignorance or an ‘I don’t care’ place?”

Opioid settlement money was paid for a body count, and every dollar spent on a pickleball court is a dollar the dead were supposed to buy for the living.

The question has a dollar figure attached now. KFF Health News, working with Johns Hopkins and Shatterproof, went through roughly 17,500 individual expenditures and found that state and local governments spent about $3.7 billion in settlement funds in 2025. Most of it went where it should: treatment, recovery housing, naloxone, prevention. But the investigation also found a $36,200 pickleball court in Gilmer County, West Virginia. It found $130,000 for Flock license-plate cameras in Carmel, Indiana, and $150,000 for street lighting in Camden, New Jersey. In Mullens, West Virginia, at least $84,000 went to city insurance, utilities and vehicle repairs. About 100 localities in 20 states put $3.7 million toward defibrillators and cardiac monitors, devices that do very little for someone whose breathing has stopped because of fentanyl.

The money was paid for the dead, and nobody was put in charge of it

To see why this keeps happening, you have to see how the money moves. The national opioid settlements with drugmakers, distributors and pharmacies are expected to total about $60 billion over nearly two decades, and local officials, county commissioners, city councils and town boards, control nearly half of it. That was a deliberate choice. Counties and cities filed many of the original lawsuits, and the theory was that the people closest to the damage would know best where to spend the repair money. In plenty of places that theory has held up. A county that funds a mobile buprenorphine van or a recovery community center is doing exactly what the deal intended.

The trouble is that the people closest to the damage are not always the people writing the checks, and nobody above them has the power to stop a bad check. Jennifer Tourville, who runs a University of Tennessee program that advises local governments on settlement spending, put the limits of her job plainly: “We aren’t permitted to tell counties what they can and cannot buy.” In Indiana, which publishes a list of things settlement money should not buy, Spencer County spent about $16,700 on eight defibrillators for the sheriff’s department anyway, even though defibrillators are on the list. A spokesperson for the state’s substance use commission explained why nothing happened: “Statute does not grant the state any enforcement authority related to how local entities spend opioid settlement funds.” In Van Buren County, Iowa, $1,000 went toward a recreation site with pickleball, bocce and tennis courts, filed as youth prevention. The county auditor said the justification “was not questioned.”

Read those three quotes back to back and the pattern is clear. The rules exist. The lists exist. The reports get filed. And then the report goes into a drawer, because the agreements were written to move money quickly to the places that sued, not to make anyone answer for how it got used. A county commissioner who would never approve a road contract without an engineer’s sign-off can approve a pickleball court as “prevention” without a single person in addiction medicine in the room. As a National Association of Counties official told the reporters, plenty of commissioners make decisions on roads without being construction experts. On roads, there is at least an engineer down the hall.

As a National Association of Counties official told the reporters, plenty of commissioners make decisions on roads without being construction experts.

Dalton Barrett is the person who should be down the hall on this one. He is a paramedic in Edgecombe County, North Carolina, who leads its post-overdose response team and oversees the county’s settlement funds, which means he knows what an overdose call actually looks like at 3 a.m. Asked about cardiac monitors bought with opioid money, he was blunt: “People that suffer from addiction are looking for trust. They’re not looking for fancy equipment.” A defibrillator restarts a heart. It does nothing for lungs that have stopped because an opioid shut down the brain’s signal to breathe. What brings that person back is naloxone, rescue breaths, and somebody who stays with them afterward. Those things are cheap. Buying them takes no gear, just people the person on the floor already trusts.

We already ran this experiment with tobacco, and we know how it ended

None of this is new. We have watched a generation of public officials take settlement money paid for one kind of death and spend it on whatever was most urgent in the budget that year. In 1998, the major tobacco companies signed the Master Settlement Agreement with 46 states, promising more than $200 billion over the following decades as payment for the cost of smoking-related illness. Public health advocates assumed a meaningful share would fund helping people quit and keeping kids from starting. It mostly didn’t. The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids has tracked it every year, and the KFF analysis puts the long-run total at less than 3% of tobacco settlement and tobacco tax revenue going to anti-smoking programs over 20 years. The rest plugged budget holes, paved roads and, in some states, paid down debt. People kept dying of tobacco the whole time.

The opioid settlements were supposed to be the lesson learned. Unlike the tobacco deal, they came with lists of approved uses and reporting requirements, and in many states with councils that include people who have lost family members. That is real progress, and it is why most of the $3.7 billion did go to the right places. But the KFF findings show where the guardrails are made of paper. A list without enforcement is a suggestion. A report nobody reads is a diary. And unlike tobacco, these payments arrive in installments through the late 2030s, which means the habits being formed in county finance offices right now will decide where tens of billions of dollars go long after this year’s headlines are forgotten.

In Arizona, the largest line item is the state prison budget

Arizona is supposed to receive about $1.2 billion over 18 years from the national opioid settlements, split between the state and its counties and cities. The state’s share alone is anticipated at about $546 million, according to the Attorney General’s office, and every dollar of it is subject to appropriation by the Legislature. That is where the Arizona version of this story gets its own shape. Here, the questionable spending isn’t a pickleball court in a small town. It’s the state itself.

In 2024, Governor Katie Hobbs and the Republican-controlled Legislature agreed to move $115 million in settlement money into the budget of the Arizona Department of Corrections, Rehabilitation and Reentry to cover a shortfall. Attorney General Kris Mayes sued, and a court temporarily blocked the transfer before the deal went forward. Then this spring, the state Auditor General’s single audit for the year ending June 30, 2024 found that the corrections department had spent $50.9 million of settlement money on hepatitis C treatment for people in prison, without records showing the spending met the settlement’s approved purposes. The settlement allows hepatitis C treatment when the infection is tied to injection opioid use. The department, KJZZ’s Camryn Sanchez reported, did not document that link patient by patient. Its own medical director had told staff that 3,850 of 3,900 hepatitis C patients also had a substance use disorder history, and the department estimates at least 95% contracted the virus through injecting opioids. It has agreed to a corrective plan.

The settlement allows hepatitis C treatment when the infection is tied to injection opioid use.

Be fair to the corrections department here, because the fairness actually sharpens the point. Curing hepatitis C in people who got it from a needle is real opioid harm reduction. Prisons are where a huge share of people with opioid use disorder end up, and treating them is a legitimate use of abatement money. The problem is what the money replaced. The state already owes people in its custody medical care. When settlement dollars pay for care the prison budget was going to cover anyway, the result is a budget backfill dressed up as abatement. Mayes’s spokesperson, Richie Taylor, said the money “should have been spent in communities that needed help all along.” The Attorney General’s own tracking page shows the pattern continuing: of about $71.45 million in reported state-share spending for fiscal 2026, the largest single item is a $40 million appropriation for the corrections department. Prison reentry programs in four counties got $8 million. The Department of Health Services got $1 million.

If you live in Arizona and you are trying to get into treatment this winter, those numbers are about you. Arizona has spent most of the past decade near the bottom of national rankings for behavioral health access. Our coverage of the recent overdose decline showed how much of the progress depends on Medicaid, which faces its own cuts in January. Settlement money was supposed to be the flexible, long-term money that filled the gaps a Medicaid card doesn’t cover: recovery housing deposits, peer navigators, transportation to a methadone clinic forty miles away. Every year it spends filling the corrections budget is a year it isn’t doing that.

The fix is to give the money to the people who know what it’s for

Burke Beaty’s answer to all of this is simple, and it is the right one: “This whole opioid settlement should be run by the people who’ve lost everything.” That isn’t sentimental. It’s a governance design. Most settlement agreements already ask for advisory councils, and many states seat parents who lost children and people in recovery on them. What those councils usually lack is a veto. Give them one. Require that any expenditure outside the core approved list (treatment, naloxone, recovery housing, peer support, prevention) get a public vote by a council where at least half the seats belong to people with lived or family experience. New Jersey lawmakers are moving in this direction with bill A5588, which would require the state human services department to review local spending reports and make localities pay back misused funds. Arizona’s Legislature could do the same with the state share in its next session, and the counties could adopt it on their own tomorrow.

Until then, people in the field have more power than they think. Settlement spending reports are public, and the OpioidSettlementTracker and county finance pages make most of them searchable. If you run a treatment program, a recovery residence or a harm reduction site, here is one thing to do this week: pull your county’s last settlement report, find the line items that don’t serve people who use drugs, and bring a one-page alternative to the next board meeting. A specific counteroffer (this many naloxone kits, this many peer navigator hours, this many recovery-housing deposits for the same dollar figure) is far harder to vote down than a complaint. Counties that fund the right things almost always got there because someone in the room knew what the money could buy.

If the news about where this money went makes you angry, that’s the right reaction. Some of what it was promised for is still yours. Naloxone has been sold over the counter since the FDA approved it in 2023, and many Arizona counties and harm reduction groups give it away free, often paid for with this same settlement money. Ask for it at a pharmacy, a library, a health department. Keep one in your bag. More on the rules and the money lives in our policy and funding coverage, our Arizona Watch section, and our opioids hub.

More on the rules and the money lives in our policy and funding coverage, our Arizona Watch section, and our opioids hub.

The tobacco money disappeared into budgets so gradually that by the time anyone added it up, the people who were supposed to benefit were already gone. The opioid money still has fifteen years of installments to go. There’s time to do this differently, but only if the people Burke Beaty is talking about, the people left behind, get a vote on what the dead paid for.

Filed Under

policysocial-culturaltreatmentOpioid SettlementArizonaFundingHarm ReductionInvestigative JournalismThe Treatment Gap

Keep up with the reporting.

One email each morning with the stories that put days like this in context.

A daily, no-spam briefing. Unsubscribe anytime.

Continue reading

More from this section