On the night of December 21, 2023, four days before Christmas, Christy Chavez called her son Jesse to dinner and heard snoring through his bedroom door. Loud, wrong snoring. She forced the door. Jesse was 20, face up on his bed, foam at his mouth. A friend called 911 while another helped her drag him to the floor. That June he had told her he’d started taking pills and couldn’t stop; she had driven him to a treatment program in Las Cruces. He was good at math. Only half a pill was found in his room. “I knew when I held my son in my hands that he was gone and it was too late,” she told the Albuquerque Journal’s Colleen Heild.
For two and a half years, Chavez assumed the pill came from a dealer and a supply chain nobody controlled. Then, in June, a federal agent said out loud that somebody had been controlling it, or could have. “This is the greatest betrayal,” she said.
The federal government chose a bigger case over the pills it could have taken off the street, and Albuquerque is right to send the invoice.
On Thursday, the City of Albuquerque did exactly that. City Attorney Joshua Boone sent the Drug Enforcement Administration a formal administrative claim for more than $153 million, alleging that DEA agents knowingly let fentanyl pills enter the city from 2023 through 2025 and that the practice “helped proliferate and spread an epidemic of addiction, overdoses.” The itemized costs read like a municipal autopsy: more than $106 million in public health and personal injury response, $25.4 million for Albuquerque Fire Rescue, $7 million in extra police calls, $4.5 million in expanded overdose response, $631,104 in crime-lab costs. “We are putting the DEA on notice,” Boone said, while admitting that collecting would be “an uphill battle.” The DEA declined to comment, citing pending investigations.
”We poisoned our community to make cases”
To understand the bill, you have to understand the tactic, which agents call “walking.” When investigators running a wiretap learn that a shipment is about to change hands, they have two choices. They can seize it, which takes the drugs off the street but tips off the network and usually ends the case at the level of the courier. Or they can watch it go, keep listening, and climb the ladder toward the people who run the operation. Law enforcement has walked drugs for decades. What makes Albuquerque different is the drug, the volume, and the fact that the Justice Department had a written rule against doing it with fentanyl.
The Associated Press reported in June, based on records and interviews with three current and former agents, that the DEA let hundreds of thousands of fentanyl pills reach New Mexico streets between 2023 and 2025. One June 2023 delivery at an Albuquerque mobile home park involved 74,000 pills, a figure prosecutors later confirmed in a court filing. Special Agent David Howell, a Navy veteran with 19 years at the agency, says at least 1.8 million pills moved unseized in a single multistate investigation; a former DEA supervisor told the AP the true number was “millions.” Howell also reported separate observed deliveries of 150,000 and 50,000 pills to the Justice Department’s internal watchdog in early 2024. “We poisoned our community to make cases,” Howell told the AP. “We did nothing but sit back and watch.”
The written rule matters here. A two-page 2017 DOJ document known as the Fentanyl Protocols directed agents to stop fentanyl distribution “as soon as practicable” and called public safety paramount. In 2024 the protocols were revised to give agents more discretion to weigh public safety against the value of keeping an investigation alive. The DEA’s position is that its decisions were “lawful, reasonable under the circumstances,” supported by court-authorized wiretaps, and aimed at the larger organizations whose dismantling saves more lives. Alex Uballez, New Mexico’s U.S. attorney during the period, put the philosophy in six words: “The bigger fish are worth catching.” He also argued that pill counts estimated from intercepted phone calls are unreliable.
In 2024 the protocols were revised to give agents more discretion to weigh public safety against the value of keeping an investigation alive.
That argument deserves a fair hearing, so here it is. In May 2025 the investigation Howell describes produced more than 3 million seized pills, the largest fentanyl bust in DEA history. A 2024 review by DOJ’s Office of Professional Responsibility found the decisions reasonable and identified no “specific danger to public health.” If you believe supply-side enforcement shrinks the overall flood, you can tell yourself the walked pills were the price of the 3 million.
Here is the problem with that math. The people who swallowed the walked pills do not get to be averaged against the bust. Howell told CBS News in October about a 2023 stop where his team, tracking a suspect from the air, watched the suspect’s SUV pick up a child. They pulled it over and found 6,000 to 7,000 pills and a gun “in a little compartment underneath the seat that the child was sitting on.” He says prosecutors chastised his team for the seizure. “They were perfectly willing to allow that fentanyl to go to the house with the kid.” Howell has since spent more than a year on desk duty and been barred by prosecutors from testifying in federal court, citing his “pattern of refusing to heed” directives to let drugs go. Two other agents have filed retaliation complaints.
New Mexico went the wrong way while the country went the right one
Every story about fentanyl in late 2026 has to sit next to the good news, because the good news is real. Overdose deaths have fallen nationally for more than three straight years, according to CDC provisional counts, the longest sustained decline in decades. The AP noted that deaths fell 14% nationwide last year. In New Mexico they rose 21%. The Albuquerque Journal, citing CDC data, reports that New Mexico had the largest increase in overdose deaths of any state between June 2025 and June 2026. Sandoval County, which includes Rio Rancho, where Jesse Chavez died, saw fatal overdoses rise 74% in a year, according to state health officials. Local officials in the Albuquerque area have declared a state of emergency over overdose calls.
We have written before about how the national decline left the Southwest behind. Nobody can prove from public data that walked pills caused New Mexico’s divergence, and we are not going to pretend otherwise. Overdose curves move for a dozen reasons at once: what is in the supply, who has naloxone, who lost insurance, who just got out of jail with a tolerance of zero. New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez, who opened a criminal investigation in June at the governor’s request and later sued the Justice Department for its records, has been careful in his own phrasing. “There’s no escaping the conclusion that New Mexico moving in the wrong direction seems to be directly connected,” he told CBS. Seems to be. That is a prosecutor leaving himself room, and it is the honest place to stand until the records come out.
What we can say without hedging is this: a state with the worst trend in the country is a state where an agency of the federal government decided, more than once, that a known shipment of the most lethal drug in the supply was worth letting through. You do not need a regression model to see that the burden of proof belongs to the people who let it walk, not to the mothers asking where the half pill came from.
In July, at the annual Walk for Lives in Rio Rancho’s Haynes Park, the DEA, which sponsors the event in other cities, stayed away “out of respect for community concerns.” About 80 people came anyway. An 18-year-old named Elijah stood up and told the crowd he had overdosed about a dozen times, been revived every time, and was four months into recovery. Rosalie Bustamante drove up from Las Cruces to talk about her son Angel, 34, who had tried to get clean, told her he did not want to live that way, and died of fentanyl poisoning anyway, leaving three kids. If you are reading this as someone who has been revived, you already know what Elijah knows: the second chance is not the system’s gift. It is luck plus whoever was holding the naloxone.
If you are reading this as someone who has been revived, you already know what Elijah knows: the second chance is not the system’s gift.
Arizona has watched federal agents let the product walk before
If this story feels familiar to anyone in Phoenix, it should. Between 2009 and 2011, the ATF’s Phoenix Field Division ran Operation Fast and Furious, in which agents watched straw buyers purchase roughly 2,000 firearms and let the guns “walk” across the border instead of seizing them, hoping to trace them up to cartel leadership. The trace never worked. In December 2010, Border Patrol agent Brian Terry was shot and killed near Rio Rico, Arizona, and two rifles from the operation were found at the scene. The DOJ Inspector General’s 2012 review found a “series of misguided strategies, tactics, errors in judgment, and management failures” and a failure to weigh the risk to public safety. Congress held hearings. Officials resigned. Everyone promised it would not happen again. Fifteen years later, in the next state over, current and former DEA agents are making the same comparison to the AP, and the product is not rifles but pills that kill at a few milligrams. The lesson of Fast and Furious was supposed to be that you cannot trace your way out of a risk you chose to release. We apparently have to learn it per product.
The difference this time is who is keeping score. In 2011, the cost of Fast and Furious was counted mostly in federal hearing rooms. In 2026 it is being counted by a city finance department, line by line, ambulance run by ambulance run. Albuquerque’s demand letter is a legal formality that preserves the right to sue the federal government later. It is also the first serious attempt to put a number on what walking does to a place, and the number is not small.
There is a practical question buried in all of this for anyone who works in treatment or harm reduction along the I-25 and I-10 corridors, including here in Arizona, which shares the same trafficking geography. You cannot control what federal agents choose to seize. You can control what your patients walk out of your building holding. If you run an emergency department, a detox, a jail health program, or an outpatient clinic, the move this week is concrete: every patient leaving after an opioid-involved visit should leave with naloxone in hand, not a prescription for it, and every intake should ask the plain question, “Are you using pressed pills?” The answer tells you whether the person thinks they are taking a 30-milligram oxycodone or knows it is fentanyl, and that changes the conversation you need to have. Bring that question to your next team meeting. It costs nothing.
What the half pill is still asking
Here is what has not changed while the lawyers trade letters. Naloxone has been sold over the counter since the FDA approved it for non-prescription use in 2023. It is on pharmacy shelves in New Mexico and Arizona without a prescription, and many health departments and harm reduction programs hand it out free. That is still yours, whatever happens to the DEA’s investigation. If you use alone, there are services like Never Use Alone built so that someone knows where you are and can send help. These are not policy positions. They are the reason Elijah was standing in Haynes Park.
The investigations will grind on. The DOJ Inspector General has an open review the DEA administrator himself requested. The state AG has a criminal probe and a records lawsuit. A congressional committee is asking questions. The DEA says, “If improvements are identified, DEA will implement them.” Maybe. The agency’s own whistleblower spent three years telling managers exactly what the improvement was. He was told to sit at a desk.
Christy Chavez moved back to Grants after Jesse died. She has held protest signs downtown. She still does not know where the half pill came from, and she may never know. What she knows now, and what the city of Albuquerque is now saying in writing with a dollar figure attached, is that the people with the wiretaps knew more than she did about where a lot of those pills were going, and decided to watch. The bill for that decision is $153 million. The city’s math does not have a line item for Jesse. Nobody’s does.
She still does not know where the half pill came from, and she may never know.
Sources Cited
- 01.BFlood of fentanyl has cost Albuquerque more than $153 million, city saysAlbuquerque Journal
- 02.BA mother's grief turns to shock, anger over DEA's fentanyl strategyAlbuquerque Journal
- 03.BMourning fentanyl deaths: Families, people in recovery tell their storiesAlbuquerque Journal
- 04.BStaggering amounts of fentanyl hit streets as DEA watched and took no action, records showAssociated Press / PBS NewsHour
- 05.B
- 06.AA Review of ATF's Operation Fast and Furious and Related MattersU.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General
- 07.AProvisional Drug Overdose Death CountsCDC National Center for Health Statistics
- 08.A
- 09.BNever Use AloneNever Use Alone Inc.
Filed Under
policysocial-culturalharm-reductionFentanylDEANaloxone
Keep up with the reporting.
One email each morning with the stories that put days like this in context.