By August, there were six people left in a house built for sixteen. The program on Bonita Avenue in North Berkeley had been almost full in January. Then staff told the remaining residents it was closing. One of them was a young man whose family, speaking to Berkeleyside on condition of anonymity, said he had finally started to get better there. Group therapy hadn’t done much for him at first. A weekly social worker and a therapist the family called “wonderful” did. When his roommate left, he got his own room, and that small privacy seemed to matter. He wasn’t ready to move home, so on Sept. 30, when Bonita House closed its dual-diagnosis residential program for good, he went to a sober living house in Berkeley. According to his family, it has fewer staff, and the other residents drink and use. “That was the last stop between severe mental illness and homelessness,” a relative said of Bonita House. “Bonita House saved his life, really, and kind of saved all our lives.”
When the only program built for both illnesses closes, the person doesn’t get half the care. They get none of it.
That’s the stake in a closure that drew one local news story and no statewide headlines. Bonita House was, according to Alameda County officials, the county’s only residential program of its kind. Its residents lived with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder and an addiction to alcohol or drugs. Most had already been through police and the courts at least once. Stays ran three to six months, sometimes a year. The building now sits empty except for a caretaker.
Being sick in two ways at once means most systems treat you as somebody else’s patient
“Dual diagnosis” is clinical shorthand. In plain terms: you hear voices, or your thinking breaks apart under stress, and you drink or use in a way you can’t stop. Each problem feeds the other. Meth or heavy cannabis can bring on psychosis or make it worse (our methamphetamine pillar walks through how). Alcohol quiets the voices for an evening and makes them louder by the weekend. Missed antipsychotic doses mean more chaos, and more chaos means more using. If you have lived this, you already know the trap: the mental health program says get sober first, and the addiction program says get stable first. You are expected to fix one illness alone so that someone will agree to treat the other.
This is not rare. In its 2024 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, SAMHSA counted 21.2 million American adults with both a mental illness and a substance use disorder in the past year. Of those, 6.9 million had a serious mental illness, the tier that includes the psychosis Bonita House was built for. Look at what happens to that 6.9 million. Just 19.2 percent, about 1.3 million people, got treatment for both conditions. Another 48.6 percent got only mental health care. A tiny 2.3 percent got only substance use treatment. And 29.9 percent, roughly 2.1 million people, got nothing for either. Those are SAMHSA’s own figures, and they say the default outcome for a person with schizophrenia and an addiction is that one of the two illnesses goes untreated, or both do.
Kenneth Minkoff, the psychiatrist who spent decades trying to rebuild public systems around this population, coined a phrase for the fix: co-occurring disorders are “an expectation, not an exception.” Every door into care should be ready for both. The phrase caught on, and the funding mostly didn’t. A program like Bonita House is what “an expectation” looks like when someone actually builds it: a bed, a psychiatrist who doesn’t kick you out for a positive test, a counselor who doesn’t treat your antipsychotic as a relapse, and enough months for both illnesses to settle at once. Almost nobody pays for that.
The county’s position is that Bonita House had become unworkable. “The program was just really struggling so much, and really not a viable program,” Kate Jones, director of adult and older adult care for the Alameda County Behavioral Health Department, told Berkeleyside. The county had already tried to rescue it. Bonita House shut down temporarily in late 2023 and restructured, and the county raised its Medi-Cal reimbursement from 10 patients to as many as 16. It never got back to 16. Jones said the remaining residents “were placed in settings that were appropriate for the level of care that they needed,” and that other county programs should be able to absorb people who would have gone there.
Bonita House shut down temporarily in late 2023 and restructured, and the county raised its Medi-Cal reimbursement from 10 patients to as many as 16.
Maybe so. But “absorb” is the problem. A family member describing a sober living where housemates drink is a direct report from inside “appropriate for the level of care.”
The evidence for integrated care is thin, and that’s an argument for more programs, not fewer
A county budget office looking for a reason to stop paying for something like Bonita House can find one in the research. Rize isn’t going to pretend otherwise.
In 2019, a Cochrane team led by Glenn Hunt reviewed 41 randomized trials covering 4,024 people with serious mental illness and substance misuse. They tested cognitive behavioral therapy, motivational interviewing, skills training, contingency management, and integrated care models. The conclusion was blunt: “we did not find any high-quality evidence to support any one psychosocial intervention over standard care.” That held for staying in treatment, for cutting substance use, and for mental health outcomes. The authors also flagged the reason, noting that “methodological difficulties exist which hinder pooling and interpreting results.” The trials were small, different from one another, and short.
That result is easy to misread, so here is what it does and doesn’t say. It doesn’t say integrated care fails. It says nobody has run trials big enough or alike enough to prove which version works best, for a population that drops out of research studies for the same reasons it drops out of treatment: psychosis, homelessness, arrest, using. Two decades earlier, Robert Drake, Minkoff and colleagues wrote in Psychiatric Services that dual-diagnosis services were emerging as an evidence-based practice after 20 years of development. They also wrote that high-quality programs were rare even where states said they were implementing them. Drake’s group named the ingredients: a long-term, staged approach to recovery, assertive outreach, and motivational work. That looks a lot like a residential program with six-month stays and a weekly social worker who keeps showing up.
The honest summary for a clinician: the signal is real but noisy, the gold-standard proof doesn’t exist, and the comparison condition, “standard care,” is itself the thing that leaves 30 percent of people with nothing. When the evidence can’t separate one good model from another, the defensible response is to keep a range of them open. It isn’t to close the one in your county and hope the leftover system catches people it was never built to hold.
The closure also didn’t happen in a vacuum. In June, Bonita House closed its Berkeley Wellness Center on University Avenue. Berkeleyside tied that closure to new state rules under Proposition 1. Prop 1, which voters approved in 2024, reorganized California’s mental health tax money into the Behavioral Health Services Act and added a $6.38 billion bond for treatment beds and housing. Starting July 1, 2026, most counties must split that money 30 percent to housing, 35 percent to Full Service Partnerships and 35 percent to everything else. The California Budget & Policy Center put the consequence plainly: “counties are cutting back on vital services, especially in prevention and early intervention.” Prop 1 also, for the first time, made substance use treatment an allowed use of that money. On paper, that was a win for people like Bonita House’s residents. In practice, the same reshuffle that opened the door to addiction care squeezed the line items that kept smaller programs alive. Meanwhile, Berkeley’s own budget cuts eliminated its Mobile Crisis Team, which had run since 1979.
California has emptied beds on a promise before
We have watched this state close the place where people with serious mental illness lived and promise something better in the community. In 1967, Gov. Ronald Reagan signed the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, which made it far harder to hold someone in a psychiatric hospital against their will. The state hospitals were already shrinking: about 36,300 patients in 1953 and about 18,800 by 1968, according to Disability Rights California. The idea was that community programs would catch the people the hospitals let go. Bonita House, which opened in Berkeley in 1971, was one of those community programs, one of the places that was supposed to make deinstitutionalization humane. Critics have since documented how the promised community facilities were underfunded from the start, and how jails and sidewalks absorbed the difference. Fifty-five years later, one of the places built to catch people has closed, and the county is again promising that other programs will catch them.
The idea was that community programs would catch the people the hospitals let go.
Nobody in this story is a villain, and that’s what makes the pattern so hard to break. The county subsidized a struggling program for years. The nonprofit kept a sixteen-bed house running through a pandemic and a 2023 shutdown-and-restructure. Prop 1’s authors really were trying to get housing to people dying on the street. But a system that funds housing or treatment, mental illness or addiction, a county contract or a Medi-Cal bed, will keep losing the people who need all of it at once. Those people also happen to be the hardest to keep enrolled, which looks like failure on a census report and makes them the easiest program to cut.
If you work in this field in the East Bay, or anywhere a program like this just disappeared, there is something concrete to do this week. Pull the list of residential and recovery-housing programs you actually refer to. Call each one and ask three questions out loud: Will you admit someone who is on an antipsychotic? Will you admit someone who used last week? Will you keep a resident who has a psychotic episode, or will you discharge them? Write the answers down and share them with your team. Many program websites dodge exactly these questions, and the family in this story learned the answers the hard way. Rize’s treatment and recovery coverage will keep tracking where integrated beds open and close.
What is still open tonight
If you are living with both of these illnesses, or loving someone who is, here is what hasn’t closed. In Alameda County, the county’s Drug Medi-Cal handbook lists a 24/7 substance use line at 1-844-682-7215 and the ACCESS line at 1-800-491-9099 for mental health and substance use referrals. Medi-Cal still covers residential addiction treatment through that system, and you can ask, at that first call, to be assessed for both conditions together rather than one at a time. Anywhere in the country, 988 answers for a mental health crisis and a substance use crisis alike, and you don’t have to choose which one you’re calling about. If you’re outside California, Rize’s Find Help search can filter for programs that treat co-occurring conditions. Mutual-help rooms like the ones we wrote about last week are still there too, even if they weren’t built for psychosis.
That young man in the sober living house is a test of whether the system works. His family thinks he’s at risk. He’s living among people who are using, without the social worker who finally reached him. Whether he stays well now depends mostly on luck, and on the people who love him being willing to keep fighting a system that keeps routing him to the wrong door.
A county can call that “absorbed.” The family has a different word for where he was before Bonita House, and they used it: homelessness. The house on Bonita Avenue stood between him and that for a while. Now the caretaker is the only one there.
Sources Cited
- 01.B
- 02.A
- 03.APsychosocial interventions for people with both severe mental illness and substance misuse (Hunt et al., Cochrane 2019)Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
- 04.A
- 05.AProposition 1 — An OverviewCalifornia DHCS
- 06.BQ&A: Preparing for California's Behavioral Health Services ActCalifornia Budget & Policy Center
- 07.BHistory of the LPS ActDisability Rights California
- 08.BHow a flawed 1967 law affects California today. Can it be fixed?Center for Health Journalism (USC Annenberg)
- 09.BKenneth Minkoff on co-occurring disorders as an expectationBehavioral Health News
- 10.AAlameda County DMC-ODS Beneficiary Handbook (2024)Alameda County Behavioral Health
Filed Under
psychologytreatmentpolicyPolysubstanceFamilies & CaregiversRecovery HousingThe Treatment GapCMS / MedicaidFundingGovernment DataStigma
Keep up with the reporting.
One email each morning with the stories that put days like this in context.