Skip to main content

Treatment Programs Stopped Walking People to Meetings. The Numbers Just Caught Up.

A national study of 2.8 million treatment discharges finds weekly mutual-help attendance among inpatients fell from 53.9% to 39.2% in seven years, with the deepest gaps for Latino, Black and Native patients. The meetings didn't go anywhere.

ByThe Rize NewsroomNovember 16, 20269 min readAlcohol

Jocellyn Harvey had been sober about a year when the Obamas left the White House in January 2017. She lived in northern New England, which meant that most nights she was the only Black person in the room. When she tried to talk about what that winter felt like, the fear, the news, the weight of it, the answer she got from people in the program was some version of: that’s an outside issue. She wrote later that she walked away from those conversations feeling “spiritually unfit,” as if her worry were a defect in her recovery instead of a fact of her life. Finding another Black person at a meeting, she wrote, was “both a rarity and a delight.”

She stayed. She found a sponsor who could hear her, drove to out-of-town meetings, and built a second fellowship out of Black people in recovery she met online. Not everyone does that much work to find a seat. A new national study suggests that, more and more, people leaving alcohol treatment aren’t finding one at all.

The meetings didn’t fail people in treatment. Treatment programs stopped walking them there.

The rooms got quieter, and it started before the pandemic

The study, published today in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs by Sarah E. Zemore and Katherine Karriker-Jaffe of the Public Health Institute’s Alcohol Research Group, looked at nearly 2.8 million discharges from alcohol treatment between 2015 and 2022. The data come from SAMHSA’s Treatment Episode Data Set, the federal record that publicly funded programs file every time someone leaves care. The question was simple: in the 30 days before discharge, did this person go to a mutual-help meeting, meaning AA or a group like it, at least four times? Call that weekly.

In 2015, 53.9% of people in inpatient alcohol treatment did. By 2019, before anyone had heard of COVID-19, it was 49.8%. In 2020 it fell to 41.7%, which makes sense: church basements closed and meetings moved to Zoom. But it didn’t bounce back. By 2022 it was 39.2%. Outpatient programs started lower and slid too, from 19.7% to 16.0%. After adjusting for who was in treatment, the odds of weekly attendance in 2022 were about half of what they had been in 2015 for inpatients and about a third lower for outpatients.

That matters because these are not people wandering in off the street. These are people already inside a treatment program, with counselors, schedules and a discharge plan. Inpatient treatment is the one moment in a drinking life when somebody can literally put you in a van and drive you to a meeting. For most of the last century that is exactly what residential programs did. The decline is not a story about the fellowship losing its appeal to the general public. It is a story about what happens, or doesn’t, between a treatment bed and the first folding chair.

Before we argue about why, it’s worth being clear about what’s being lost, because the evidence here is unusually strong. In 2020, John Kelly, Keith Humphreys and Marica Ferri published a Cochrane review, the most cautious kind of evidence summary in medicine, on AA and the counseling approach built to get people into it. In the randomized trials, people steered toward AA were about 21% more likely to stay completely abstinent for a full year than people given other proven treatments such as cognitive behavioral therapy (two trials, 1,936 people, rated high-certainty evidence), and the advantage held at two and three years. On most other drinking outcomes, AA did about as well as the alternatives, not better. That’s the honest shape of it: not a miracle, but one of the few things in addiction care that is free, open every day, and holds up when you test it. “Mutual-help groups are widely available, low-cost and one of the most effective resources we have,” Zemore said in the release.

On most other drinking outcomes, AA did about as well as the alternatives, not better.

The people falling out are the people who already had the fewest seats

The overall drop is the headline. The gaps underneath it are the story. Compared with white patients, and after adjusting for age, sex, income and other factors, the study found Latino patients had 36% to 39% lower odds of weekly attendance. Black patients had 28% lower odds. American Indian and Alaska Native patients had 22% to 28% lower odds. Asian and Pacific Islander patients were the exception, with 60% to 66% higher odds. Young adults aged 18 to 24 and people over 65 were less likely to attend than people in middle age. Women were slightly more likely to attend than men.

The study can’t say why, and the authors are careful not to pretend it can. But they offer an explanation that anyone who has walked into the wrong meeting will recognize: some people stay away from groups they experience as built for white men, or where they’ve met suspicion or worse. They also note that in some cities, Black clients attend at higher rates, which suggests the problem may be less about the program itself and more about being the only one in the room. Harvey’s story is that finding in a person. The meeting was open to her. It was not built for her, and when she brought her whole self through the door, she was told to leave part of it outside.

There’s a psychology to this that doesn’t show up in a regression table. Mutual help works, as far as researchers can tell, mostly through the people in it. When you watch someone who was exactly where you are now get out and stay out, it does something no doctor’s reassurance can. Psychologists call it vicarious mastery; the plain version is that the proof is the person, not the pamphlet. That mechanism has a catch built in. If nobody in the room looks like you, talks like you, prays like you or drinks like your family drank, the proof is weaker. You can sit through a hundred shares and never hear your own story. If you have ever left a meeting feeling lonelier than when you walked in, you already understand the finding better than any odds ratio can explain it.

A second explanation in the paper is less comfortable for the treatment field. Over the last decade, addiction care has moved, rightly, toward medication and away from the idea that total abstinence is the only real recovery. Some 12-step rooms have been slow to accept people on medication, and some members still tell newcomers that a pill for alcohol or opioids isn’t “real” sobriety. The researchers suggest that friction may have pushed programs and patients away from groups altogether. Karriker-Jaffe’s answer is the right one: “Medications and mutual-help groups aren’t competing options. Many people do best with both.” If the field swapped one tool for the other instead of stacking them, that is a failure of nerve, not progress.

We integrated these rooms once, on purpose, and it took work

None of this is new, and that should give us some hope. The first Black AA groups formed in 1945, in St. Louis, Chicago and Washington, D.C., because Black drinkers were not welcome in the white ones. The recovery historian William White describes local meetings moving through stages over the following decades: barring Black members outright, then admitting them only to open meetings, then as “observers,” then designating certain meetings “interracial,” and finally swapping speakers between Black and white groups until the walls came down. White quotes Joe McQuany, who got sober in Arkansas: “Little Rock was no place for a black man to be looking for help in 1962.” By the late 1970s, in White’s telling, AA had become “a coat of many colors,” and the meetings in those church basements may well have been the most integrated setting in America. That didn’t happen because the Big Book changed. It happened because specific people carried specific invitations across specific lines, again and again. The lesson for 2026 is the same one: belonging is not a policy. It is a ride, a phone number, and someone who says “come with me.”

It happened because specific people carried specific invitations across specific lines, again and again.

That is exactly the work the study suggests treatment programs have stopped doing. The authors recommend that programs actively connect patients with meetings where they feel they belong, encourage mutual help whether or not someone takes medication, and stop assuming that simply pointing at the nearest 12-step meeting will close the gaps. They name concrete fixes: more Spanish-language meetings, referrals to culturally adapted groups, and connection to peer support specialists and recovery community centers.

For a program director, that translates into a list you can start this week. Add the TEDS question, four or more meetings in the last 30 days, to your own discharge review and look at your numbers by race, age and language before the state does. Before anyone leaves inpatient care, have a staff member or peer specialist go with them to one meeting, in person or online, and write the name of that meeting in the discharge plan instead of “attend AA.” Keep a short, current list of Spanish-language meetings, meetings for people of color, LGBTQ meetings, and medication-friendly options like Medication-Assisted Recovery Anonymous, and update it every quarter. If your counselors still tell patients on naltrexone or buprenorphine that they’ll have to hide it at meetings, bring that to your next team meeting and end it there.

The door is still open tonight

Here’s the part the numbers can’t capture, and the part we want you to hold onto if you’re the one reading this from inside early recovery. The decline in this study is a decline in referrals, not in the meetings themselves. They are still there, tonight, in almost every town in America and online around the clock, and they still cost nothing. You can find one through AA’s meeting finder, which filters by language and format, and if the first one feels like a room built for somebody else, that is information about the room, not about you. Try another. Try one for people who look like you or talk like you. Bring your medication with you and don’t apologize for it. You can also read more lived-experience reporting from our newsroom and our alcohol coverage, including why most heavy drinkers say no clinician ever asked them about it.

There’s a reason the most protective thing in alcohol recovery is also the cheapest. It runs on people showing up for each other, and that has never needed a grant. It does need an invitation. For seven years, fewer and fewer people leaving treatment got one, and the ones least likely to get one were the ones the rooms had already failed to make room for.

Jocellyn Harvey did not wait to be invited. She drove to other towns and found her people online. She shouldn’t have had to. The next person leaving a 28-day program with a discharge sheet that just says “AA” deserves what she had to build herself: someone who walks them to the door, and a room where they don’t have to leave half of themselves outside.

Filed Under

psychologysocial-culturaltreatmentAlcoholPeer SupportThe Treatment GapStigmaPeer-Reviewed ResearchGovernment DataRelapse Prevention

Keep up with the reporting.

One email each morning with the stories that put days like this in context.

A daily, no-spam briefing. Unsubscribe anytime.

Continue reading

More from this section