The DEA Rescheduling Hearing Excluded the People It Was About — Don't Call the Outcome Legitimate Yet
As post-hearing briefs come due, the process that will decide cannabis's federal fate was never actually open to the public it claims to serve
The DEA Rescheduling Hearing Excluded the People It Was About — Don’t Call the Outcome Legitimate Yet
Today is the deadline DEA Chief Administrative Law Judge Derek Julius set for post-hearing briefs and transcript corrections, closing the record on an 11-day rescheduling hearing that wrapped July 15 without a single camera in the room.
A process this closed doesn’t earn the outcome it produces, whichever way it breaks.
Only designated participants got a seat, and reform advocates who wanted to argue for moving cannabis off Schedule I were not among them. The hearing was not livestreamed, despite earlier assurances that it would be. The people whose access to treatment, employment, housing, and criminal records turn on this decision watched from outside a room they weren’t allowed into, while a docket built mostly from rescheduling opponents shaped the record Judge Julius will now summarize. Multiple lawsuits challenging the process are still pending, which tells you the objection isn’t fringe — it’s structural.
Here’s the part that should bother supporters of rescheduling as much as opponents: none of this actually decides anything. Judge Julius doesn’t reschedule marijuana. He writes a recommendation. It goes to DEA Administrator Terrance Cole, a single political appointee, who can accept it, shred it, or sit on it. Two years, eleven hearing days, a closed room, and a contested transcript all funnel into one person’s discretion. That’s not administrative process working as designed — it’s a stalling ritual with the mechanics of due process and none of its openness.
The stakes of getting this wrong keep growing on both sides. New research flagged in Marijuana Moment’s Sunday roundup found that state-level legalization increased agricultural employment by roughly 9% in adopting states, with minimal wage disruption — a labor-market finding that cuts directly against the crime-and-harm framing rescheduling opponents leaned on inside that closed hearing room. If the people making the case against rescheduling never had to answer data like that in open argument, the record Julius is summarizing was thin by design, not by accident.
None of this means Schedule III is the right call, or that Schedule I should stay put. It means the process generating that answer forfeited the credibility to make it feel settled. A recommendation built on a hearing the public couldn’t watch, decided by participants opponents dominated, handed to one appointee for a final call — that’s not a verdict. It’s a procedural fig leaf, and everyone downstream of it, patients and providers included, should treat it that way until Terrance Cole’s signature actually lands on something.
Sources Cited
- 01.A
- 02.A
Filed Under
policytrendsDEA
Keep up with the reporting.
One email each morning with the stories that put days like this in context.
Continue reading
More from this section
Opioid Settlement Money Is Buying Pickleball Courts. The People It Was Paid For Are Still Waiting.
Local governments spent $3.7 billion in opioid settlement money in 2025, including a $36,200 pickleball court and $130,000 in police cameras. In Arizona, an audit questioned $50.9 million spent by the prison system. What the money was for, and who should decide.
Policy & FundingThe Senate Just Told SAMHSA to Explain Its Own Harm Reduction Rules. Grantees Have Been Asking All Year.
The Senate's FY27 Labor-HHS bill funds SAMHSA at about $7.46 billion, rejects merging NIDA and NIAAA, and orders SAMHSA to give grantees 'timely and clarifying guidance' on harm reduction. The deadline that matters is December 11.
Policy & FundingThe DEA Watched Fentanyl Walk Into Albuquerque. Now the City Is Sending the Bill.
Albuquerque says DEA agents let millions of fentanyl pills reach its streets to build bigger cases, and it wants $153 million. Here is what 'walking' cost, who paid, and why Arizona has seen this movie before.