Think about the way cannabis fits into a day once it has really moved in. A vape pen in the car because it doesn’t smell. A joint on the porch after work because that’s the ritual. A gummy before bed because sleep doesn’t come without it anymore. Maybe a dab on the weekend because the pen stopped doing much. None of those feels like a big decision. Each one has its own reason, its own place, its own little story about why it’s fine. Add them up and something else is going on.
A team at NYU Langone just put a number on that something.
The number of ways you use cannabis tells you more about where you stand than how often you think you use it.
The study, led by Omar El-Shahawy with senior author Joseph Palamar and published in Addictive Behaviors, took 17,732 American adults who had used cannabis in the past month, drawn from the 2022–2023 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, the federal government’s big annual household survey on drug use. The researchers used a statistical method that sorts people into groups based on patterns, here, which forms of cannabis they used, and four groups fell out. Nearly half (48%) mostly smoked. About a fifth (21%) smoked and vaped. About 17% mostly ate edibles. And 14% used nearly everything: smoking, vaping, edibles, dabbing concentrates, the full menu. The researchers call that last group “polymodal.” You could call them the people for whom cannabis has a form for every hour.
Two out of three people in the every-form group met criteria for a disorder
Cannabis use disorder is the clinical name for when use has turned into something you can’t easily steer: you use more than you meant to, you’ve tried to cut back and couldn’t, it’s crowding out things you care about, you feel lousy when you stop. In the NYU data, about 67% of the polymodal group met criteria for it. For people who smoked and vaped, it was 47%. For people who mostly smoked, 36%. For people who mostly ate edibles, 15%.
Daily use followed the same staircase. About half of the polymodal group used every day, compared with 31% of smoke-and-vape users, 28% of mostly-smokers, and about 13% of edible users. “Our findings suggest that using cannabis in multiple forms may be a red flag for heavier use and symptoms of addiction,” El-Shahawy said.
Now the limits, because they matter and because you deserve to know them. This is a snapshot survey. People reported their own use, and people misremember and underreport. It shows that using many forms travels with heavier use and disorder. It does not show that picking up a vape pen causes a disorder, and the study didn’t ask anyone why they chose the forms they did. The arrow could easily run the other way: people who are already in deep may reach for more forms because one stopped being enough. For a clinician, that is not a reason to ignore the finding. It is a reason to treat it the way you would a blood-pressure reading, a cheap signal worth following up, not a diagnosis.
We have written before about how tolerance flattens the high even as the dose climbs. The every-form pattern looks like the behavioral version of that same chase. When one route stops delivering, you add another.
Why more forms could mean more hooks
The study didn’t test mechanism, so what follows is interpretation, flagged as such. Two ideas from addiction science fit the pattern well.
The first is plain pharmacology. Different forms hit differently. Smoking and vaping deliver THC to the brain within minutes and wear off fast. Edibles take an hour or more and last for hours. Concentrates carry far more THC per hit than flower. Use all of them and you can keep a steady level of THC in your system almost around the clock, which is exactly the condition under which the brain adjusts and starts to expect it. NIDA notes that frequent use and higher-potency products raise the risk of developing a use disorder, and the polymodal group is, almost by definition, both.
NIDA notes that frequent use and higher-potency products raise the risk of developing a use disorder, and the polymodal group is, almost by definition, both.
The second is about cues, the ordinary sights, places, and moods that your brain learns to pair with using. Every form you add comes with its own set of triggers: the car for the pen, the porch for the joint, the bedtime for the gummy. That’s more doorways into a craving and fewer places in your day that don’t have one. If you have ever tried to cut back on one form and found yourself simply using a different one at that hour, you have felt this from the inside.
The demographics hint at a generational trend. Adults aged 18 to 25 made up nearly a third of both the smoke-and-vape and the every-form groups, but only about a sixth of the mostly-smoke group. Women made up more than half the edibles group. People who smoked cannabis were more likely to also smoke cigarettes. The legal market has made every form easy to buy in a single trip, and the youngest adults are the ones using the full catalog.
We have learned the hard way that the form matters
In the summer of 2019, emergency rooms started filling with young, previously healthy people who couldn’t breathe. Their lungs looked on scans like they’d inhaled something toxic, because they had. By February 2020, the CDC had counted 2,807 hospitalizations and 68 deaths from what it named EVALI, vaping-associated lung injury, and traced most cases to THC vape cartridges, many bought from informal sources and cut with vitamin E acetate. For years the public conversation about cannabis had been a single yes-or-no question: is weed dangerous? EVALI showed that was the wrong question. The danger lived in the form, and in who made it. The NYU findings make the same point about dependence instead of lungs: it isn’t just whether you use, it’s how many routes you’ve built.
This matters for people who are trying to make honest sense of their own use. A separate study published this month in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, drawing on more than 415,000 adults, found 57% higher odds of suicidal thoughts among adults with cannabis use disorder, a link that held steady from 2014 to 2023. That study, too, can’t show cause. But taken together, the two papers sketch a picture that people in the cannabis-recovery community describe all the time: a slow slide in which nothing ever felt like a crisis, until the mood was worse and the use was everywhere.
The one question worth asking
If you use cannabis and are wondering where you stand, you don’t need a survey. Count your forms. If the number has gone up over the last year, if you have a pen, a jar, a bag of gummies, and something stronger, and each has its own time of day, that’s worth taking seriously, not as a verdict but as information. Picking one form and one time, and noticing how hard that is, tells you a lot.
For anyone running an intake, the move this week is simple: add one question to your cannabis screen. Not just “how often” but “in what ways: smoke, vape, edibles, concentrates?” A yes to three or four is a quick, cheap flag that this person may need a fuller assessment, and it’s a question people answer honestly because it doesn’t sound like judgment.
Cannabis use disorder is treatable, and people get out of it. NIDA lists behavioral treatments, including cognitive behavioral therapy and contingency management, as the approaches with evidence behind them, and there is a whole cannabinoids hub on this site, plus our running harm reduction coverage, with more on what helps. The every-form pattern isn’t a sentence. It’s a map of how deep the roots go, and maps are how you find your way back out.
It’s a map of how deep the roots go, and maps are how you find your way back out.
Sources Cited
- 01.AEl-Shahawy et al., cannabis consumption-mode classes and cannabis use disorder (Addictive Behaviors, vol. 184, 108829)Addictive Behaviors (Elsevier)
- 02.BScientists discover a hidden warning sign of cannabis addictionNYU Langone Health via ScienceDaily
- 03.BCannabis addiction linked to 57% higher odds of suicidal thoughtsJournal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs via ScienceDaily
- 04.A
- 05.A
Filed Under
trendsharm-reductionsocial-culturalCannabisVaping
Keep up with the reporting.
One email each morning with the stories that put days like this in context.